And I've never done that before. But I had to do something to give it closure. To give it a place. What exactly? I'll explain that to you in this blog.
I don't work on commission, well. almost never then. If I really like something I sometimes want to do it. Or... if I'm tempted. So I had accepted a commission, for a book cover. Sound fun? So I thought! I liked the story a lot and wanted to give it a shot.
And yet it went wrong
I didn't notice it at first, but as the process progressed, a longer and longer list of things the illustration had to comply with emerged. Big thing this, colours this, this has to go with it, this and that. Oh and a tight deadline, of course. The 'red flag' should have been that I got nasty jitters in my underbelly when an AI generated image was sent along with: this is what we are looking for.
Now I have made some books before and so far I have always been 100% free in what I make. Feedback: fine, tips are welcome of course, but generally that's also what I say beforehand: I need freedom. And yet I unconsciously wormed my way into all kinds of jobs to make what matched all the lists. Result: it didn't turn out pretty (I thought so myself, opinions are divided), not me, I wasn't happy with it.
I went along with it
After feedback from the publisher, I saw where I was going wrong. Too much adjustment, not feeling free, trying frenetically to make what was required of me. I saw it as a learning process and offered to make something totally new really from within myself. I was happy, found (and still find) it beautiful and I was sure that this free feeling would be noticed and would be right.
The bomb
unfortunately, it was not what they were looking for. They asked me if I wanted to make a third illustration within 2 days (just for reference, about 8 hours of work per illustration and for someone who can only work 4 hours a day....). Then I came back to my own feelings, the values I stand for. I want to create what I like, what is good for me, have fun in what I do. I want to choose my health, cosiness, slow living. But ouch... this did hurt really bad! Insecurity, sadness, anger, more insecurity, sadness and anger. Lying awake for a night, imagining all sorts of things (I would be a really bad person and the entire country would know because I stopped this assignment).
It could not continue
I decided to stop the project myself. I realised that the fun was gone (which could never benefit the work) and I did not have the confidence that a third version would be accepted. I had not signed a contract, so that offered advantages and disadvantages. Advantage: I was free to quit. Disadvantage: all the total 18 hours spent on this project I don't get paid.
Fire!
And then I had to give it a place, process it. The frustration, uncertainty, balking at myself (why did I let myself be tempted). I tidied up my desk, archived all the files on the computer far away, put away the files on the Ipad as well, archived the emails and... ritually burnt the illustrations. Never done it before (bad idea too generally) but it was necessary this time. Finding closure, seeing my uncertainty go up in flames.
And now?
Is it over? No, of course not! I will still carry it in the back of my mind for a while I think. But I have done some things that are very helpful:
-Feeling consciously bad for a while (because hiding away is counterproductive)
-Being gentle with myself today
-I gently forced myself to get started on new projects. Making Christmas cards is just around the corner and it did me good to immerse myself in ideas and sketches. Hide in my own cosy world.
-Keep repeating to myself: remember your core values. 'I want to make what I feel like, if people happen to like it, that's a bonus'. I want to live calm and relaxed, I want to be okay with myself and enjoy myself. Basically, I went back to my basis, deep inside myself.
-Decided not to be tempted by commissioned work anymore (which immediately means my last commissioned book is coming out in September, a gulp moment though)
-Hiking, yin yoga and picking a card from my inspiration card set.
-I wrote this blog (it really helps)
You are my hero!
Yes, you read it right! YOU, you are the main player here. Because of your support, your orders, your sharing on social media and your telling friends about my work, I don't HAVE to take orders and I can choose for myself. I can make what I like, what makes me happy and whenever I want. So you are my hero and for that I am grateful. I also realise enormously what a luxury it is (though even this is not always easy, running an online shop has stress things too for sure). It's a choice and I choose you! Thank you for being here!
ps. The reason I don't share the illustrations in question is because it's about the feelings, the process and the story and not an opinion about my work.... Or something like that. Well... you get the point.
pps. In case you immediately feel like giving me extra support: here's my selection from today that helps me out!
-
plate home in the woods / sheet home in the woods€7,95 incl. VAT
-
Messages from the woods - inspiration cards€29,95 incl. VAT
Super handsome Esther! I find it really inspiring how you handle this and other setbacks 💪💫
Ahh how sweet! Sometimes when you encounter setbacks it can feel quite lonely, but everyone has setbacks, big and small! Nice to be able to inspire each other in how to deal with them I thought! Big hugs!
Dear Esther,
No one thinks you can't do it. Your inner critic can get the pip!
So much love in your work, because you had fun while creating it. Don't like it? Then maybe it's not your taste and you choose something else. But you are happily aware of it.
Clean up, head up and get on with your own cosy world!
With love,
Aahhh Joke, this is SO sweet! Thank you for these kind words!
Hi Esther,
You have no idea who I am, but for what it's worth:
I bought some cards from you in a shop in my town the other day. Because I thought they were so beautiful and cosy. I very enthusiastically forwarded them to a friend.
She; ohh that's from Esther Bennink!
Me; euh, if you say so.
A month later, my mother was at a fair, near the stand with 'magic' lamps.
She: isn't this something for you?
Me: ohhh that's from Esther Bennink!
Meanwhile, I have 2 lamps, a set of cards and plates for the lamp, and my next order on the way.
Moral of the story: your style, your illustrations, make impact. I don't know any other illustrator by name. You may bale, you may feel bad about a collaboration that fails, etccccc. but please, never doubt yourself.
Your original idea was to capture 'cosyness' in atmospheric illustrations, right? You do that. You do just that.
Just so you know.
Hey Taya, What an incredibly cute, sweet post! Thank you! And how nice that you too are a 'kindred spirit' when it comes to cosiness! Big hug!
Someone once told me that failure is not a failure, but an important and precious step in our eternal learning process. I think that applies here too.
Yaa exactly! We are a few weeks on now and that's really how it is yes!
Hi Esther,
Your illustrations make me so happy and calm!
And you're absolutely right. Do what makes YOU happy!
Have ordered again because you illustrate the life I would like to have.
I often check your website to see if you have made something sweet again and to read your blog.
Kind regards, Linda
Hey Linda, how sweet and fun! And that my illustrations make you happy and calm is the biggest compliment you can give me, thank you! Love!
Hay hay,
I just found you through a Facebook ad (I think). You have beautiful inspiring work. I also tried commissioned work and stopped too. Best decision ever. If you can definitely keep your own freedom because when you have to, sometimes the flow stops and then the inspiration goes away. Everything you make feels like straight from your heart. Lovely. I can step right into your work and feel at home. That is very special. Take care of yourself! We need people like you ♡.
Hey Yvette, how nice that you found me, cozy! And be welcome, love! Esther
How brave, vulnerable and strong that you share this... what a process to stay true to yourself! And what an example... your bravery, to take it on... to process, feel... and then just do it! That touches me... in your illustrations, and in your writing! Thank you for being yourself!
Hey Lenneke, what a sweet comment, thank you! Lots of love!
Fantastic isn't it that other people are made happy by the things you make that make you happy?
Your drawings exude this and that is why there is such a need for it.
How sweet! And it immediately inspires me again to paint nicely this week, thanx!